Adventures in Eating & Cooking

Cupcakes Day!

With the sweet summery sunshine and clear blue skies, today was a perfect day for cupcakes! So Zinni, Neta, and I got off at 2nd Ave. Lower East side on the F train to embark on our journey to cupcake paradise.

Very close to this subway station there is a newly opened 2nd location for Pinisi Bakery, our first destination. Compared to few tall chairs by a bar-like table jammed together in the 1st location (on 128 E 4th St.), this Pinisi had a lot more space to eat, so we stayed around to enjoy our cupcake. In fact, in the back there was a rather classy and cozy couch to rest on, along with some unique artworks and colorful lights. There was definitely effort put into interior design for the 2nd Pinisi.

Interior of Pinisi

Interior of Pinisi

However, I felt there was less variety of treats at this location. I couldn’t find the firey chocolate red velvet cupcake that I loved so much in the 1st location. But at least it still had Pinisi‘s famous regular red velvet cupcake! The three of us split it, relishing the fluffy cake smothered in a sweet rich, but far from overwhelming cream cheese frosting. The frosting was extremely delicious, but I thought this made the red velvet cake itself seem paler…And I eat cupcakes for the cake, not the frosting, so I was a bit disappointed. However, if you’re really a frosting person and you love the sweet creamy sensation of cream cheese frosting, go for this!

Pinisi's Awesome Red Velvet

Pinisi's Awesome Red Velvet

Next we walked down to 7th Ave. to check out Butter Lane, which I’ve recently read fabulous reviews about.

Butter Lane, a cute quaint wonderful little bakery!

Butter Lane, a cute quaint wonderful little bakery!

And wow…I know why it got such great reviews. Butter Lane was the closest to cupcake paradise with its heavenly cupcakes.

Although there wasn’t much selection, you could customize your cupcake by choosing the cake flavor and then the frosting. Neta chose banana cupcake, and I thought chocolate frosting would go best. But then there was American chocolate frosting and French chocolate frosting, and since American chocolate frosting evoked the image of overly sweet transfatty Betty Crocker stuff, we decided on French.

We made the right choice. Our French chocolate frosted banana cupcake was amazing! The cake was fluffy, moist, and bursting with warm banana flavor, which was enhanced by the light chocolatey frosting. The frosting worked perfectly with the cupcake. It was whipped into a soft mousse-like texture, very airy; and unlike most frosting, it was not overwhelmingly sweet. This cupcake was true bliss.

Amazing French chocolate frosted banana cupcake from Butter Lane!

Amazing French chocolate frosted banana cupcake from Butter Lane!

Last on the list is one of my all-time favorites: Babycakes! Edible for vegan vegetarians, Jews (kosher), diabetics, lactose intolerant people, and people with other allergies, the sweets at Babycakes can really brighten up anyone‘s day!


Babycakes, a little bit of awesomeness for everyone!

However, instead of getting cupcakes here, we got brownies on my recommendation. I love Babycakes‘ brownies! They’re usually rich, moist, and chocolatey, bursting with molten chocolate in the center. But this time the brownies weren’t as good as I had expected, and I’m not sure why. Perhaps it was just a bad day, or maybe the agave nectar ones are just weird, but the brownies on the dry side and they weren’t stuffed with as much gooey chocolate as usual. Nonetheless, they were still pretty good, healthy, and available to all!

Babycakes' Yummy Brownies

Babycakes' Yummy Brownies

Ooey Gooey Innards

Ooey Gooey Innards

Grade: Pinisi B+, Butter Lane A+, Babycakes A-/A

Conclusion: Almost reached cupcake paradise in Butter Lane! Neta experienced a cupcake coma while eating the red velvet cupcake at Pinisi. Zinni was really impressed by the lack of “necessary” sweets ingredients at Babycakes. It was tons of fun, and super-delicious! I was pretty satsified by the treats today.



18 1st Ave
New York, NY 10009-7907
Get Directions

(212) 673-3345

Butter Lane

123 East 7th Street
New York, NY 10009
Get Directions

(212) 677-2880


248 Broome St
New York, NY 10002
Get Directions

(212) 677-5047

11 comments on “Cupcakes Day!

  1. Anonymous
    July 7, 2009

    I agree that the frosting at Pinisi was better than the cake itself. However, I think the amazing frosting made up for the cake! The frosting at Butter Lane was great as well, as was their cake. Oh and, Babycakes had a buy-one-get-one-free promotion today! Their brownies were really good too, but a little too bitter.
    Nice post! And great pictures 🙂


  2. AT
    July 7, 2009

    It’s true that the frosting was better than the cake at Pinisi. However, I think the frosting definitely made up for the cake that slightly lacked in flavor. The cupcake at Butter Lane was great–both the cake and the frosting…it was just a little to sweet. The brownies at Babycakes were very good as well, just a bit too bitter. But cupcake buying was a great way to spent a Monday afternoon–we must do it again some time!


  3. Pingback: Martha’s Cupcakes « Munchi Monster

  4. Pingback: Third Cupcake Post in a Row! « Munchi Monster

  5. kuchiko
    August 8, 2009

    the red velvet cake from pinisi makes my mouth drool =p… i like cream cheese frosting, so i’ll definitely like it. and i must try butter lane! cupcake paradise, of course i must visit! the frosting just sound delightful, like whipped cream =]


  6. Pingback: Cupcake Truck [Very Overdue Post] « Munchi Monster

  7. Pingback: Cupcake Truck Revisited! « Munchi Monster

  8. athenaxie
    July 2, 2010

    the pinisi cupcake looks so pretty! the butter lane one looks kinda ugly >< well…at least it has a beautiful taste.


    • bubblepeachtea
      July 19, 2010

      Pfft, ugly or not it tasted the best!!! And it wasn’t ugly, it was just kind of plain-looking…


  9. Pingback: Flying Monkey Patisserie « Munchi Monster

  10. Pingback: TGIF Cupcakes – The Return of Buttercream Truck | Munchimonster

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: